extratags should become null when empty

[nominatim.git] / test / bdd / db / import / parenting.feature

diff --git a/test/bdd/db/import/parenting.feature b/test/bdd/db/import/parenting.feature
index 7974fe521c1ad0c1f7349e0de9748832a888e29b..c349b69f63ee1b1b03053189cf078e02e584148f 100644 (file)
--- a/test/bdd/db/import/parenting.feature
+++ b/test/bdd/db/import/parenting.feature
@@ -3,42 +3,49 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
     Tests that the correct parent is chosen
 
     Scenario: Address inherits postcode from its street unless it has a postcode
     Tests that the correct parent is chosen
 
     Scenario: Address inherits postcode from its street unless it has a postcode

-        Given the scene roads-with-pois
+        Given the grid with origin DE
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    |   |   |   |   |    |
+         |    | 1 |   | 2 |   |    |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | housenr | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | 4       | :p-N1 |
+         | osm | class | type  | housenr |
+         | N1  | place | house | 4       |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | housenr | postcode | geometry |
-         | N2  | place | house | 5       | 99999    | :p-N1 |
+         | osm | class | type  | housenr | postcode |
+         | N2  | place | house | 5       | 99999    |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name  | postcode | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name  | postcode | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | galoo | 12345    | :w-north |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | galoo | 12345    | 10,11    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |
          | N2     | W1 |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |
          | N2     | W1 |

-        When searching for "4 galoo"
+        When sending search query "4 galoo"

         Then results contain
         Then results contain

-         | ID | osm_type | osm_id | langaddress |
-         | 0  | N        | 1      | 4, galoo, 12345 |
-        When searching for "5 galoo"
+         | ID | osm | display_name |
+         | 0  | N1  | 4, galoo, 12345, Deutschland |
+        When sending search query "5 galoo"

         Then results contain
         Then results contain

-         | ID | osm_type | osm_id | langaddress |
-         | 0  | N        | 2      | 5, galoo, 99999 |
+         | ID | osm | display_name |
+         | 0  | N2  | 5, galoo, 99999, Deutschland |

 
     Scenario: Address without tags, closest street
 
     Scenario: Address without tags, closest street

-        Given the scene roads-with-pois
-        And the places
-         | osm | class | type  | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | :p-N1 |
-         | N2  | place | house | :p-N2 |
-         | N3  | place | house | :p-S1 |
-         | N4  | place | house | :p-S2 |
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 | 2 |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 3 | 4 |    |
+         | 20 |   |   |   |   | 21 |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class | type  |
+         | N1  | place | house |
+         | N2  | place | house |
+         | N3  | place | house |
+         | N4  | place | house |

         And the named places
          | osm | class   | type        | geometry |
         And the named places
          | osm | class   | type        | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | :w-north |
-         | W2  | highway | residential | :w-south |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | 10,11    |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | 20,21    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |


@@ -48,17 +55,23 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | N4     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: Address without tags avoids unnamed streets
          | N4     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: Address without tags avoids unnamed streets

-        Given the scene roads-with-pois
-        And the places
-         | osm | class   | type  | geometry |
-         | N1  | place   | house | :p-N1 |
-         | N2  | place   | house | :p-N2 |
-         | N3  | place   | house | :p-S1 |
-         | N4  | place   | house | :p-S2 |
-         | W1  | highway | residential | :w-north |
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 | 2 |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 3 | 4 |    |
+         | 20 |   |   |   |   | 21 |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class   | type  |
+         | N1  | place   | house |
+         | N2  | place   | house |
+         | N3  | place   | house |
+         | N4  | place   | house |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class   | type        | geometry |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | 10,11    |

         And the named places
          | osm | class   | type        | geometry |
         And the named places
          | osm | class   | type        | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway | residential | :w-south |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | 20,21 |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |


@@ -68,17 +81,70 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | N4     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street tag parents to appropriately named street
          | N4     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street tag parents to appropriately named street

-        Given the scene roads-with-pois
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 | 2 |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 3 | 4 |    |
+         | 20 |   |   |   |   | 21 |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | street| geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | south | :p-N1 |
-         | N2  | place | house | north | :p-N2 |
-         | N3  | place | house | south | :p-S1 |
-         | N4  | place | house | north | :p-S2 |
+         | osm | class | type  | street|
+         | N1  | place | house | south |
+         | N2  | place | house | north |
+         | N3  | place | house | south |
+         | N4  | place | house | north |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name  | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name  | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | north | :w-north |
-         | W2  | highway | residential | south | :w-south |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | north | 10,11    |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | south | 20,21    |
+        When importing
+        Then placex contains
+         | object | parent_place_id |
+         | N1     | W2 |
+         | N2     | W1 |
+         | N3     | W2 |
+         | N4     | W1 |
+
+    @fail-legacy
+    Scenario: addr:street tag parents to appropriately named street, locale names
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 | 2 |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 3 | 4 |    |
+         | 20 |   |   |   |   | 21 |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class | type  | street| addr+street:de |
+         | N1  | place | house | south | Süd            |
+         | N2  | place | house | north | Nord           |
+         | N3  | place | house | south | Süd            |
+         | N4  | place | house | north | Nord           |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class   | type        | name  | geometry |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | Nord  | 10,11    |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | Süd   | 20,21    |
+        When importing
+        Then placex contains
+         | object | parent_place_id |
+         | N1     | W2 |
+         | N2     | W1 |
+         | N3     | W2 |
+         | N4     | W1 |
+
+    Scenario: addr:street tag parents to appropriately named street with abbreviation
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 | 2 |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 3 | 4 |    |
+         | 20 |   |   |   |   | 21 |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class | type  | street   |
+         | N1  | place | house | south st |
+         | N2  | place | house | north st |
+         | N3  | place | house | south st |
+         | N4  | place | house | north st |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class   | type        | name+name:en | geometry |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | north street | 10,11    |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | south street | 20,21    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |


@@ -88,17 +154,21 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | N4     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street tag parents to next named street
          | N4     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street tag parents to next named street

-        Given the scene roads-with-pois
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 | 2 |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 3 | 4 |    |
+         | 20 |   |   |   |   | 21 |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | street | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | abcdef | :p-N1 |
-         | N2  | place | house | abcdef | :p-N2 |
-         | N3  | place | house | abcdef | :p-S1 |
-         | N4  | place | house | abcdef | :p-S2 |
+         | osm | class | type  | street |
+         | N1  | place | house | abcdef |
+         | N2  | place | house | abcdef |
+         | N3  | place | house | abcdef |
+         | N4  | place | house | abcdef |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name   | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name   | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | abcdef | :w-north |
-         | W2  | highway | residential | abcdef | :w-south |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | abcdef | 10,11    |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | abcdef | 20,21    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |


@@ -108,64 +178,74 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | N4     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street tag without appropriately named street
          | N4     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street tag without appropriately named street

-        Given the scene roads-with-pois
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 |   |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 3 |   |    |
+         | 20 |   |   |   |   | 21 |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | street | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | abcdef | :p-N1 |
-         | N2  | place | house | abcdef | :p-N2 |
-         | N3  | place | house | abcdef | :p-S1 |
-         | N4  | place | house | abcdef | :p-S2 |
+         | osm | class | type  | street |
+         | N1  | place | house | abcdef |
+         | N3  | place | house | abcdef |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name  | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name  | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | abcde | :w-north |
-         | W2  | highway | residential | abcde | :w-south |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | abcde | 10,11    |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | abcde | 20,21    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |

-         | N2     | W1 |

          | N3     | W2 |
          | N3     | W2 |

-         | N4     | W2 |

 
     Scenario: addr:place address
 
     Scenario: addr:place address

-        Given the scene road-with-alley
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   | |   |
+         |    | 1 | | 2 |
+         | 11 |   | |   |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type   | addr_place | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house  | myhamlet   | :n-alley |
+         | osm | class | type   | addr_place |
+         | N1  | place | house  | myhamlet   |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name     | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name     | geometry |

-         | N2  | place   | hamlet      | myhamlet | :n-main-west |
-         | W1  | highway | residential | myhamlet | :w-main |
+         | N2  | place   | hamlet      | myhamlet | 2 |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | myhamlet | 10,11 |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | N2 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street is preferred over addr:place
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | N2 |
 
     Scenario: addr:street is preferred over addr:place

-        Given the scene road-with-alley
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |  |   |   |
+         |    |  | 1 | 2 |
+         | 11 |  |   |   |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type   | addr_place | street  | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house  | myhamlet   | mystreet| :n-alley |
+         | osm | class | type   | addr_place | street  |
+         | N1  | place | house  | myhamlet   | mystreet|

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name     | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name     | geometry |

-         | N2  | place   | hamlet      | myhamlet | :n-main-west |
-         | W1  | highway | residential | mystreet | :w-main |
+         | N2  | place   | hamlet      | myhamlet | 2        |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | mystreet | 10,11    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Untagged address in simple associated street relation
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Untagged address in simple associated street relation

-        Given the scene road-with-alley
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 2 |   | 3 |   |    |
+         |    |   |   |   |   |    |
+         | 12 | 1 |   |   |   |    |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | :n-alley |
-         | N2  | place | house | :n-corner |
-         | N3  | place | house | :n-main-west |
+         | osm | class | type  |
+         | N1  | place | house |
+         | N2  | place | house |
+         | N3  | place | house |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | foo  | :w-main |
-         | W2  | highway | service     | bar  | :w-alley |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | foo  | 10,11 |
+         | W2  | highway | service     | bar  | 10,12 |

         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |
          | 1  | W1:street,N1,N2,N3 | associatedStreet |
         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |
          | 1  | W1:street,N1,N2,N3 | associatedStreet |


@@ -177,16 +257,22 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | N3     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Avoid unnamed streets in simple associated street relation
          | N3     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Avoid unnamed streets in simple associated street relation

-        Given the scene road-with-alley
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 2 |   | 3 |   |    |
+         |    |   |   |   |   |    |
+         | 12 | 1 |   |   |   |    |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | :n-alley |
-         | N2  | place | house | :n-corner |
-         | N3  | place | house | :n-main-west |
-         | W2  | highway | residential | :w-alley |
+         | osm | class | type  |
+         | N1  | place | house |
+         | N2  | place | house |
+         | N3  | place | house |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class   | type        | geometry |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | 10,12    |

         And the named places
          | osm | class   | type        | geometry |
         And the named places
          | osm | class   | type        | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | :w-main |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | 10,11    |

         And the relations
          | id | members                      | tags+type |
          | 1  | N1,N2,N3,W2:street,W1:street | associatedStreet |
         And the relations
          | id | members                      | tags+type |
          | 1  | N1,N2,N3,W2:street,W1:street | associatedStreet |


@@ -198,89 +284,107 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | N3     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Associated street relation overrides addr:street
          | N3     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Associated street relation overrides addr:street

-        Given the scene road-with-alley
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |    |   |    | 11 |
+         |    |    |   |    |    |
+         |    |    | 1 |    |    |
+         |    | 20 |   | 21 |    |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type  | street | geometry |
-         | N1  | place | house | bar    | :n-alley |
+         | osm | class | type  | street |
+         | N1  | place | house | bar    |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | residential | foo  | :w-main |
-         | W2  | highway | residential | bar  | :w-alley |
+         | W1  | highway | residential | foo  | 10,11    |
+         | W2  | highway | residential | bar  | 20,21    |

         And the relations
         And the relations

-         | id | members            | tags+type |
-         | 1  | W1:street,N1,N2,N3 | associatedStreet |
+         | id | members      | tags+type |
+         | 1  | W1:street,N1 | associatedStreet |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Building without tags, closest street from center point
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W1 |
 
     Scenario: Building without tags, closest street from center point

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |  |   |   | 11 |
+         |    |  | 1 | 2 |    |
+         | 12 |  | 4 | 3 |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class    | type        | geometry |
-         | W1  | building | yes         | :w-building |
-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | :w-NS |
+         | osm | class    | type        | geometry    |
+         | W1  | building | yes         | (1,2,3,4,1) |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | 10,11       |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | 10,12       |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | W1     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: Building with addr:street tags
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | W1     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: Building with addr:street tags

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |  |   |   | 11 |
+         |    |  | 1 | 2 |    |
+         | 12 |  | 4 | 3 |    |

         And the named places
          | osm | class    | type | street | geometry |
         And the named places
          | osm | class    | type | street | geometry |

-         | W1  | building | yes  | bar    | :w-building |
+         | W1  | building | yes  | foo    | (1,2,3,4,1) |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | 10,11    |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,12    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |

-         | W1     | W2 |
+         | W1     | W3 |

 
     Scenario: Building with addr:place tags
 
     Scenario: Building with addr:place tags

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   |
+         |    | 1 | 2 |   | 9 |
+         | 11 | 4 | 3 |   |   |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | N1  | place    | village     | bar  | :n-outer |
-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | N9  | place    | village     | bar  | 9        |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | 10,11    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class    | type | addr_place | geometry |
-         | W1  | building | yes  | bar        | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type | addr_place | geometry    |
+         | W1  | building | yes  | bar        | (1,2,3,4,1) |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |

-         | W1     | N1 |
+         | W1     | N9 |

 
     Scenario: Building in associated street relation
 
     Scenario: Building in associated street relation

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |  |   |   | 11 |
+         |    |  | 1 | 2 |    |
+         | 12 |  | 4 | 3 |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class    | type | geometry |
-         | W1  | building | yes  | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type | geometry    |
+         | W1  | building | yes  | (1,2,3,4,1) |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | 10,11 |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,12 |

         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |
         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |

-         | 1  | W1:house,W2:street | associatedStreet |
+         | 1  | W1:house,W3:street | associatedStreet |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |

-         | W1     | W2 |
+         | W1     | W3 |

 
     Scenario: Building in associated street relation overrides addr:street
 
     Scenario: Building in associated street relation overrides addr:street

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |  |   |   | 11 |
+         |    |  | 1 | 2 |    |
+         | 12 |  | 4 | 3 |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class    | type | street | geometry |
-         | W1  | building | yes  | foo    | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type | street | geometry    |
+         | W1  | building | yes  | foo    | (1,2,3,4,1) |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | 10,11 |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,12 |

         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |
          | 1  | W1:house,W2:street | associatedStreet |
         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |
          | 1  | W1:house,W2:street | associatedStreet |


@@ -290,17 +394,19 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | W1     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: Wrong member in associated street relation is ignored
          | W1     | W2 |
 
     Scenario: Wrong member in associated street relation is ignored

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
-        And the named places
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 1 |   | 3 | 4 |   |   |    |
+         |    |   |   | 6 | 5 |   |   |    |
+         And the named places

          | osm | class | type  | geometry |
          | osm | class | type  | geometry |

-         | N1  | place | house | :n-outer |
+         | N1  | place | house | 11       |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class    | type | street | geometry |
-         | W1  | building | yes  | foo    | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type | street | geometry    |
+         | W1  | building | yes  | foo    | (3,4,5,6,3) |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,11    |

         And the relations
          | id | members                      | tags+type |
          | 1  | N1:house,W1:street,W3:street | associatedStreet |
         And the relations
          | id | members                      | tags+type |
          | 1  | N1:house,W1:street,W3:street | associatedStreet |


@@ -309,20 +415,69 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W3 |
 
          | object | parent_place_id |
          | N1     | W3 |
 

+    Scenario: street member in associatedStreet relation can be a relation
+        Given the grid
+          | 1 |   |   | 2 |
+          | 3 |   |   | 4 |
+          |   |   |   |   |
+          |   | 9 |   |   |
+          | 5 |   |   | 6 |
+        And the places
+          | osm | class | type  | housenr | geometry |
+          | N9  | place | house | 34      | 9        |
+        And the named places
+          | osm | class   | type       | name      | geometry    |
+          | R14 | highway | pedestrian | Right St  | (1,2,4,3,1) |
+          | W14 | highway | pedestrian | Left St   | 5,6         |
+        And the relations
+          | id | members             | tags+type |
+          | 1  | N9:house,R14:street | associatedStreet |
+        When importing
+        Then placex contains
+          | object | parent_place_id |
+          | N9     | R14             |
+
+
+    Scenario: Choose closest street in associatedStreet relation
+        Given the grid
+         | 1  |   |    |  | 3  |
+         | 10 |   | 11 |  | 12 |
+        And the places
+         | osm | class | type  | housenr | geometry |
+         | N1  | place | house | 1       | 1        |
+         | N3  | place | house | 3       | 3        |
+        And the named places
+         | osm  | class    | type        | geometry |
+         | W100 | highway  | residential | 10,11    |
+         | W101 | highway  | residential | 11,12    |
+        And the relations
+         | id | members                                            | tags+type |
+         | 1  | N1:house,N3:house,W100:street,W101:street | associatedStreet |
+        When importing
+        Then placex contains
+         | object | parent_place_id |
+         | N1     | W100            |
+         | N3     | W101            |
+
+

     Scenario: POIs in building inherit address
     Scenario: POIs in building inherit address

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |  |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    |  | 5 | 2 | 6 |   |    |
+         |    |  | 3 | 1 |   |   |    |
+         | 12 |  | 8 |   | 7 |   |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class   | type       | geometry |
-         | N1  | amenity | bank       | :n-inner |
-         | N2  | shop    | bakery     | :n-edge-NS |
-         | N3  | shop    | supermarket| :n-edge-WE |
+         | osm | class   | type       |
+         | N1  | amenity | bank       |
+         | N2  | shop    | bakery     |
+         | N3  | shop    | supermarket|

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class    | type | street | addr_place | housenr | geometry |
-         | W1  | building | yes  | foo    | nowhere    | 3       | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type | street | housenr | geometry    |
+         | W1  | building | yes  | foo    | 3       | (5,6,7,8,5) |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | 10,11    |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,12    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id | housenumber |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id | housenumber |


@@ -330,116 +485,132 @@ Feature: Parenting of objects
          | N1     | W3              | 3 |
          | N2     | W3              | 3 |
          | N3     | W3              | 3 |
          | N1     | W3              | 3 |
          | N2     | W3              | 3 |
          | N3     | W3              | 3 |

+        When sending geocodejson search query "3, foo" with address
+        Then results contain
+         | housenumber |
+         | 3           |

 
     Scenario: POIs don't inherit from streets
 
     Scenario: POIs don't inherit from streets

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 5 | 1 | 6 |    |
+         |    | 8 |   | 7 |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class   | type       | geometry |
-         | N1  | amenity | bank       | :n-inner |
+         | osm | class   | type  |
+         | N1  | amenity | bank  |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class    | type | street | addr_place | housenr | geometry |
-         | W1  | highway  | path | foo    | nowhere    | 3       | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type | name | street | housenr | geometry    |
+         | W1  | highway  | path | bar  | foo    | 3       | (5,6,7,8,5) |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,11    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id | housenumber |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id | housenumber |

-         | N1     | W3              | None |
+         | N1     | W1              | None |

 
     Scenario: POIs with own address do not inherit building address
 
     Scenario: POIs with own address do not inherit building address

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |  |   |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    |  | 6 | 2 | 7 |   |    |
+         |    |  | 3 | 1 |   | 5 |  4 |
+         | 12 |  | 9 |   | 8 |   |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class   | type       | street | geometry |
-         | N1  | amenity | bank       | bar    | :n-inner |
+         | osm | class   | type       | street |
+         | N1  | amenity | bank       | bar    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class   | type       | housenr | geometry |
-         | N2  | shop    | bakery     | 4       | :n-edge-NS |
+         | osm | class   | type       | housenr |
+         | N2  | shop    | bakery     | 4       |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class   | type       | addr_place  | geometry |
-         | N3  | shop    | supermarket| nowhere     | :n-edge-WE |
+         | osm | class   | type       | addr_place  |
+         | N3  | shop    | supermarket| nowhere     |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class | type              | name     | geometry |
-         | N4  | place | isolated_dwelling | theplace | :n-outer |
+         | osm | class | type              | name     |
+         | N4  | place | isolated_dwelling | theplace |
+         | N5  | place | isolated_dwelling | nowhere  |

         And the places
         And the places

-         | osm | class    | type | addr_place | housenr | geometry |
-         | W1  | building | yes  | theplace   | 3       | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type | addr_place | housenr | geometry    |
+         | W1  | building | yes  | theplace   | 3       | (6,7,8,9,6) |

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | 10,11    |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,12    |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id | housenumber |
          | W1     | N4              | 3 |
          | N1     | W2              | None |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id | housenumber |
          | W1     | N4              | 3 |
          | N1     | W2              | None |

-         | N2     | W3              | 4 |
-         | N3     | W2              | None |
+         | N2     | W2              | 4 |
+         | N3     | N5              | None |

 
     Scenario: POIs parent a road if they are attached to it
 
     Scenario: POIs parent a road if they are attached to it

-        Given the scene points-on-roads
+        Given the grid
+         |    | 10 |    |
+         | 20 | 1  | 21 |
+         |    | 11 |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class   | type     | street   | geometry |
-         | N1  | highway | bus_stop | North St | :n-SE |
-         | N2  | highway | bus_stop | South St | :n-NW |
-         | N3  | highway | bus_stop | North St | :n-S-unglued |
-         | N4  | highway | bus_stop | South St | :n-N-unglued |
+         | osm | class   | type     |
+         | N1  | highway | bus_stop |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type         | name     | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type         | name     | geometry |

-         | W1  | highway | secondary    | North St | :w-north |
-         | W2  | highway | unclassified | South St | :w-south |
+         | W1  | highway | secondary    | North St | 10,11 |
+         | W2  | highway | unclassified | South St | 20,1,21 |

         And the ways
          | id | nodes |
         And the ways
          | id | nodes |

-         | 1  | 100,101,2,103,104 |
-         | 2  | 200,201,1,202,203 |
+         | 1  | 10,11 |
+         | 2  | 20,1,21 |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |

-         | N1     | W1 |
-         | N2     | W2 |
-         | N3     | W1 |
-         | N4     | W2 |
+         | N1     | W2 |

 
     Scenario: POIs do not parent non-roads they are attached to
 
     Scenario: POIs do not parent non-roads they are attached to

-        Given the scene points-on-roads
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   | 1 |   |  11 |  | 30 |
+         | 14 |   |   |   |  15 |  |    |
+         | 13 |   | 2 |   |  12 |  | 31 |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class   | type     | street   | geometry |
-         | N1  | highway | bus_stop | North St | :n-SE |
-         | N2  | highway | bus_stop | South St | :n-NW |
+         | osm | class   | type     | street   |
+         | N1  | highway | bus_stop | North St |
+         | N2  | highway | bus_stop | South St |

         And the places
          | osm | class   | type         | name     | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class   | type         | name     | geometry |

-         | W1  | landuse | residential  | North St | :w-north |
-         | W2  | waterway| river        | South St | :w-south |
+         | W1  | landuse | residential  | North St | (14,15,12,2,13,14) |
+         | W2  | waterway| river        | South St | 10,1,11  |
+         | W3  | highway | residential  | foo      | 30,31    |

         And the ways
          | id | nodes |
         And the ways
          | id | nodes |

-         | 1  | 100,101,2,103,104 |
-         | 2  | 200,201,1,202,203 |
+         | 1  | 10,11,12,2,13,10 |
+         | 2  | 10,1,11 |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |

-         | N1     | 0 |
-         | N2     | 0 |
+         | N1     | W3 |
+         | N2     | W3 |

 
     Scenario: POIs on building outlines inherit associated street relation
 
     Scenario: POIs on building outlines inherit associated street relation

-        Given the scene building-on-street-corner
+        Given the grid
+         | 10 |   |   |   | 11 |
+         |    | 5 | 1 | 6 |    |
+         | 12 | 8 |   | 7 |    |

         And the named places
         And the named places

-         | osm | class    | type  | geometry |
-         | N1  | place    | house | :n-edge-NS |
-         | W1  | building | yes   | :w-building |
+         | osm | class    | type  | geometry     |
+         | N1  | place    | house | 1            |
+         | W1  | building | yes   | (5,1,6,7,8,5)|

         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |
         And the places
          | osm | class    | type        | name | geometry |

-         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | :w-WE |
-         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | :w-NS |
+         | W2  | highway  | primary     | bar  | 10,11    |
+         | W3  | highway  | residential | foo  | 10,12    |

         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |
         And the relations
          | id | members            | tags+type |

-         | 1  | W1:house,W2:street | associatedStreet |
+         | 1  | W1:house,W3:street | associatedStreet |

         And the ways
          | id | nodes |
         And the ways
          | id | nodes |

-         | 1  | 100,1,101,102,100 |
+         | 1  | 5,1,6,7,8,5 |

         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |
         When importing
         Then placex contains
          | object | parent_place_id |

-         | N1     | W2 |
+         | N1     | W3 |

 
     # github #1056
     Scenario: Full names should be preferably matched for nearest road
 
     # github #1056
     Scenario: Full names should be preferably matched for nearest road